Contact one of our experts

Too busy to coach? Stop adding coaching meetings and start coaching in the work

Table of Contents

Two women collaborate over a clipboard in an office, illustrating practical, on-the-job coaching and leadership development at TMS Consulting in Brisbane City, Australia

We so often hear that managers need to coach more. To be a better leader, coach more. To develop your people, coach more. To build capability, coach more. The problem is that this can make coaching sound like another task, something that sits outside the day-to-day work of managing. Another meeting. Another leadership expectation to squeeze into an already impossible day.

For time-poor managers, it’s not particularly surprising that coaching falls down the list when there is a customer issue to resolve, a deadline approaching or a decision that simply needs to be made.

So what if we’ve framed the problem incorrectly?

What if coaching doesn’t need to be something managers find more time to do? What if it becomes part of how the work gets done?

Managers don’t need another thing to do – and yet they’re victims of their own success

The pressure on managers is real. Research from CIPD found that just 53% of line managers felt they received enough support, through training and information, to carry out their people management responsibilities well. Its wider research also found clear relationships between the quality of line management and employee performance, wellbeing and engagement.

At the same time, there’s an interesting paradox in the transition into management.

We often promote people because they’re good at getting things done. They have expertise, make good decisions, solve difficult problems and know how to find an answer.  Then, as their leadership responsibilities grow, we need something quite different from them.  Their contribution becomes less about what they can personally solve, and increasingly about the capability, judgement and performance they can develop in others.  For people who have built their careers on expertise, decisiveness and being the person who knows what to do, that’s a significant shift.

And perhaps the hardest part of coaching isn’t asking a better question. It’s resisting the urge to answer it.

We know coaching works, but that doesn’t necessarily mean more coaching sessions

There is a growing evidence base for the positive effects of coaching. A 2023 meta-analysis led by Andreea Nicolau found positive effects from executive coaching, particularly on behavioural outcomes, as well as self-efficacy, psychological capital and resilience. Interestingly, the researchers also found that the number of coaching sessions did not moderate the outcomes. (Nicolau, A, 2023)

That doesn’t mean five minutes of coaching from a manager is equivalent to formal executive coaching. They’re different contexts and we should be careful not to treat them as interchangeable.  But it does give us reason to question the assumption that the positive impact of coaching necessarily comes from adding more coaching sessions to the calendar.

Perhaps the bigger opportunity for managers is to recognise the coaching moments already embedded in the work.

Coaching moments are everywhere in a manager’s day

Think about an average day.

  • Someone brings you a problem and wants to know what to do next.
  • You’re making a difficult decision at a leadership table.
  • You’re debriefing something that didn’t go well.
  • You’re delegating a stretch assignment.
  • Someone needs feedback or asks you to review their work.

These aren’t additional coaching opportunities. They are the work.

And almost everyone contains an opportunity to make a choice about where the thinking happens.

When someone brings us a problem, the fastest response is often to solve it: “Here’s what I’d do…”

In the moment, that’s efficient. We might save five minutes and move on. But we’ve also taken responsibility for the thinking.

The alternative doesn’t need to be a 45-minute coaching conversation. Sometimes it’s simply resisting the urge to answer immediately and asking a question that keeps the thinking with the other person.

One-on-one, that might be:

  • “When have you dealt with something like this before? What worked and what didn’t?”
  • “What would success look like? What would have to be true for that to happen?”
  • “What do you think we should do next?”

At a leadership table, rather than immediately adding another opinion, it might be:

  • What’s most important here? What’s the bigger picture?
  • What might we be missing? What are we not talking about that we should be?

Sometimes one question is enough to change the nature of the conversation.

Sharing the work also means sharing the thinking

There’s something important here about what we mean when we ask managers to delegate.  We usually think about delegation in terms of tasks, decisions or accountability. But managers can delegate the work while still holding much of the cognitive load around it.

If every difficult problem comes back to the manager to diagnose, every ambiguous decision is escalated upwards, and every obstacle requires the manager to identify the way forward, then the work may have been distributed but much of the thinking hasn’t.

Over time, it’s easy to see how a pattern can develop:

An employee encounters a problem. The manager provides the answer. The problem gets resolved. And the next time uncertainty arises, the employee comes back for another answer.

None of that is necessarily problematic as a one-off interaction. Managers are there to provide expertise, context and direction.

But as a repeated pattern, it can leave the manager carrying more and more of the team’s thinking while doing relatively little to build the judgement and confidence of those around them.

Coaching creates an opportunity to share not just the workload, but the thinking required to do the work well.

Good manager coaching requires agility

This doesn’t mean managers should respond to every question with another question.

There are plenty of times when withholding expertise in the name of “coaching” would be frustrating, inefficient or simply poor management.

Manager coaching also isn’t the same as executive coaching. Managers have positional authority and accountability for outcomes. They often hold organisational context or technical knowledge that matters. Sometimes ambiguity, urgency or risk means clear direction is exactly what’s required.

So good managerial coaching isn’t about adopting a single coaching style. It’s about having a broader leadership repertoire and being able to move between coaching and mentoring, directing, advising, and providing feedback.

Sometimes the person really does need: “Tell me what I need to do.”

Sometimes it’s: “Tell me what you’ve learned from doing this before.”

And sometimes it’s: “Help me think this through.”

The skill isn’t to always coach. It’s having the judgement to know when to provide the answer and when not to.

And good coaching doesn’t mean never offering advice.

A relatively ordinary conversation might start with:

  • “What’s your thinking?”, then:
  • “What might you be missing?”
  • And, if your experience adds something useful: “One thing I’d encourage you to consider is…”
  • Before handing the thinking back: “Given that, what do you think you’ll do next?”

The manager has still contributed expertise. But they haven’t necessarily taken ownership of the problem away from the other person. That distinction matters.

Perhaps we don’t need more coaching meetings

The goal of manager coaching isn’t simply to have more coaching conversations.  It’s to develop people who are increasingly capable of exercising judgement, solving problems and acting without needing every answer to come from their manager. And perhaps that’s particularly important for the time-poor managers.

Because if the answer to managerial overload is to add more coaching meetings to the diary, we’ve probably missed the point.

Instead, the challenge is much smaller.

Find the coaching opportunity in the next conversation you’re already having.

When someone brings you a problem, pause before answering. Stay with their thinking for a little longer.

And perhaps ask yourself:

Does this person need my answer right now, or do they need me to help them find theirs?

TMS Consulting works with organisations to strengthen coaching capability, through executive coaching for leaders and practical development that equips managers to coach, develop and build capability in their people.

References

Valcour, M. (2025).  How to be a great coach, even when you’re busy.  Harvard Business Review  https://hbsp.harvard.edu/product/H08XS9-PDF-ENG

Wang Q, Lai Y, Xu X, McDowall A (2022), “The effectiveness of workplace coaching: a meta-analysis of contemporary psychologically informed coaching approaches”. Journal of Work-Applied Management, Vol. 14 No. 1 pp. 77–101, doi: https://doi.org/10.1108/JWAM-04-2021-0030

Nicolau A, Candel OS, Constantin T and Kleingeld A (2023) The effects of executive coaching on behaviors, attitudes, and personal characteristics: a meta-analysis of randomized control trial studies. Front. Psychol. 14:1089797. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1089797. https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychology/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1089797/full

CIPD, 2023. Managers need better training and support to nurture happy, healthy and productive teams, finds new CIPD research | CIPD

About the author

TMS Consulting