Contact one of our experts

Beyond the Organisation Chart: What Great Organisational Design Really Requires

Table of Contents

A team collaborates around a table, discussing organisational design and workplace dynamics at TMS Consulting in Brisbane City, Australia

When organisations face challenges with performance, accountability or efficiency, a restructure can often appear to be the logical solution. Reporting lines are reconsidered. Teams are consolidated or separated. Leadership responsibilities are redistributed. A new organisational chart emerges, designed to create greater clarity, efficiency and effectiveness.

But changing an organisational structure does not necessarily change how an organisation operates.

If the underlying challenges relate to unclear functions, fragmented or duplicated processes, capability gaps or ineffective decision-making, a new structure alone is unlikely to resolve them.

Effective organisational design starts not with the organisation chart, but with a more fundamental question: how does the organisation need to operate to deliver its strategic objectives?

This distinction is what separates structural change from meaningful organisational design. It is also what distinguishes effective organisation design consultants: the ability to look beyond the presenting problem and understand what will genuinely improve organisational performance.

The Problem with Starting at Structure

Organisational structures are important. They establish reporting relationships, group functions and help clarify responsibilities.

However, they are only one component of a much broader operating model.

An organisation experiencing slow decision-making, for example, might assume its management structure has become too complex. Yet further examination may reveal that the real challenge lies in overlapping accountabilities, unclear delegations or processes requiring multiple layers of approval.

Similarly, teams experiencing duplication of effort may not necessarily need to be consolidated. The underlying issue may be a lack of clarity about functional responsibilities, inconsistent processes or poorly defined interfaces between teams.

An org structure redesign that does not address these underlying issues risks simply moving existing problems into a different configuration.

This is why effective organisation design consultants must be prepared to challenge the initial assumptions behind a proposed restructure.

The most valuable contribution is not always a recommendation to change the structure. Sometimes it is identifying that the organisation needs a different solution altogether.

Form Follows Function: Designing Around What Matters

One of the most important principles in organisational design is that form should follow function.

Put simply, organisations should first establish what work needs to be performed and what capabilities are required before deciding how that work should be organised into teams and roles.

This sounds straightforward, but it can be difficult in practice.

Existing structures are often shaped by organisational history, established leadership arrangements, individual capabilities and previous decisions. Over time, these arrangements can become accepted as the natural way an organisation should operate.

When redesigning an organisation, there can be a tendency to make incremental adjustments to these existing arrangements rather than challenge whether they remain appropriate.

A functions-first approach creates an opportunity to consider the organisation with a fresh perspective.

It asks:

  • What outcomes must the organisation deliver, now and into the future?
  • What activities and functions are essential to achieving those outcomes?
  • What capabilities, resources and decision-making arrangements are required?
  • How should functions interact to support effective service delivery?
  • What organisational arrangements will best enable people to perform their work?

These questions shift the focus from who currently does the work to what the organisation needs to achieve.

The result is a more objective foundation for developing structural options and defining roles and accountabilities.

It also creates space to identify opportunities for improved collaboration, clearer responsibilities and more effective ways of working.

Operating Model Design: Connecting Strategy to Delivery

Strategy sets the direction of an organisation. The operating model determines how that direction is translated into day-to-day operations.

Yet a common challenge is the disconnect between the two.

An organisation may have a clearly articulated strategy while continuing to operate through structures, processes and decision-making arrangements developed for a different set of priorities.

As strategic objectives evolve, the organisation’s operating model must also be considered.

Effective operating model design examines how functions, governance, processes, capabilities, structures and ways of working combine to deliver organisational outcomes.

This requires understanding the interdependencies between different parts of the organisation.

For example, introducing a more customer-focused service delivery model may require more than changing the responsibilities of customer-facing teams. It may also involve reconsidering how information is shared, how decisions are made, how supporting functions interact and where particular capabilities are located.

Likewise, an organisation seeking greater operational efficiency may need to examine the flow of work across functional boundaries rather than simply reducing management layers.

The key is recognising that organisational effectiveness depends on how the system operates as a whole.

A well-designed structure should support the operating model, not compensate for weaknesses within it.

Why the Human Element Matters

Organisational design is often approached as a technical exercise. It involves analysing functions, defining structures, establishing accountabilities and identifying the resources required to deliver organisational objectives.

But organisations are not simply collections of functions and reporting relationships. They are systems of people working together.

And people do not necessarily operate according to what is represented on an organisational chart.

Informal networks, working relationships, organisational culture, leadership behaviours and established ways of working all influence how effectively an organisation functions.

These elements can be particularly important when considering organisational change.

A technically sound design may look compelling on paper but prove difficult to implement if it does not adequately consider the people who will work within it.

This is where human-centred organisational design adds value.

Engaging leaders and employees throughout the design process can provide valuable insights into how work is actually performed, where challenges exist and what improvements may be needed.

It can also help identify the practical implications of proposed changes before decisions are finalised.

However, human-centred design does not mean designing by consensus or allowing existing preferences to dictate future arrangements.

Rather, it means combining objective analysis with a genuine understanding of the people, relationships and working practices that influence organisational performance.

The aim is to design an organisation that is both operationally effective and workable for the people responsible for delivering its outcomes.

Good Organisation Design Requires More Than a Framework

There is no shortage of established organisation design frameworks and methodologies.

Approaches such as value chain analysis, Andrew Campbell’s Operating Model Canvas and Galbraith’s Star Model provide useful ways to examine how organisations create value, align capabilities and design their operations.

These frameworks can help consultants understand existing arrangements, identify design requirements and assess potential future operating models and structures.

However, frameworks are tools, not solutions.

The effectiveness of an organisational design process depends on how well these tools are applied to the organisation’s particular circumstances.

A government agency delivering complex public services will face different design considerations from a growing private-sector business or a not-for-profit organisation operating with constrained resources.

Organisational history, regulatory requirements, workforce capabilities, culture, financial sustainability and service delivery expectations can all influence what constitutes an effective design.

This is where professional judgement becomes critical.

Experienced organisation design consultants should be able to draw on established methodologies while recognising that each organisation requires a considered, fit-for-purpose approach.

The objective is not to apply a preferred framework. It is to develop organisational arrangements that make sense for the organisation.

What Really Distinguishes Effective Organisation Design Consultants?

The value of organisation design consulting is not simply the ability to produce a well-presented organisational structure or comprehensive report.

It lies in helping leaders make informed decisions about how their organisation should operate.

This requires the ability to connect strategic priorities with operational realities, challenge assumptions constructively and identify the root causes of organisational challenges.

It also requires an appreciation of the trade-offs inherent in organisational design.

For example, increasing functional specialisation may strengthen technical capability but introduce additional coordination requirements. Consolidating responsibilities may simplify governance but create capacity constraints. Reducing management layers may improve efficiency in some areas while increasing demands on leaders in others.

There is rarely a single design that optimises every organisational objective.

Effective consultants help organisations understand these trade-offs, establish clear design principles and assess options against what matters most.

This is particularly important when comparing organisation design consulting services. Different consulting approaches may emphasise structural redesign, operating model improvement, functional analysis or organisational effectiveness more broadly.

Importantly, effective consultants recognise that organisational design is not an end in itself.

The real test is whether the resulting arrangements enable sustainable organisational performance.

Taking a More Considered Approach to Organisational Design

At TMS Consulting, our approach to organisational design reflects our belief that All Organisations are Human™.

We recognise that achieving sustainable organisational performance requires consideration of both the technical and human dimensions of how organisations operate. This means looking beyond structures and reporting lines to understand the functions, capabilities, relationships and ways of working that enable organisations to deliver their objectives.

Taking the time to understand these elements before redesigning an organisation provides a stronger foundation for meaningful, sustainable change.

Because ultimately, great organisational design is not about creating a better organisation chart. It is about creating an organisation that works better.

Let’s Talk About Organisational Design

TMS Consulting partners with organisations to review operating models, assess organisational effectiveness and develop practical, human-centred organisational design solutions.

Explore our Organisational Design services or contact our team to discuss how we can support your organisation.

About the author

TMS Consulting